- Fred Sitati questions the priorities set out in the Cooperatives Bill, 2024
- He challenges the proposed intergovernmental forum and its limited cooperative representation
- He calls for greater self-regulation and alignment with Africa’s Model Law
I invite the lawyers in the house to give their candid views on this.
My understanding of a “Long Title” in a Bill is that it gives a summary outlining the purpose for which the Bill has been prepared. It also guides courts of law in interpreting Acts of Parliament brought before them. It is more or less a “theme”. If it is a government Bill, the line ministries prepare the drafts and pass them to the draftsmen and women at the Kenya Law Reform Commission (KLRC) and the Attorney General’s office to do what they know best.
In our case, the Long Title should, in my view, express the Bill’s main objective as regulating the cooperative movement in Kenya. That being the case, the Cooperatives Bill, 2024, should have given prominence to the establishment, promotion, registration and regulation of cooperatives in a devolved system of governance, in which the Constitution created two levels that are independent but interdependent at the same time. Put differently, cooperatives come first and regulators come second. I am therefore finding it difficult to come to terms with the Long Title as it stands. The Bill instead gives prominence to the establishment of the Commissioner’s office.
I differ with the wording on several grounds. First, the Bill’s main purpose is to regulate cooperatives in a devolved system of governance. It is not being enacted to establish an office in the Public Service, where the Commissioner for Cooperative Development (CCD) falls. Second, in the two preceding Acts since independence, the establishment of the CCD’s office has been captured in Part II of the Act, titled Establishment of Offices and Administration.
Third, the offices for which specific Acts are enacted are state offices, meaning holders of constitutional offices such as the Auditor General, judges, MPs and the Controller of Budget. Their tenures of office are fixed by law, and the holders enjoy certain privileges that are not available to other public service employees. Fourth, from where I sit, the government offices, namely those of the CCD and the CCCs, are tools or instruments for enforcing the Act once it is enacted and gazetted. The real object is Kenya’s cooperative movement.
Fifth, the state offices established by specific Acts are listed in Article 260 of the 2010 Constitution, and the office of the CCD is not among them. In effect, the elevation of the CCD’s office to that of a state office within the meaning of Article 260 amounts to constitutional overreach. I raised this concern in my memorandum to the Senate last year, but apparently it never got their attention.
READ:
Sixth, the creation of the Intergovernmental Cooperative Relations Forum is equally out of order, and I will explain why. Cooperative legislation globally is about regulating cooperatives. It is not a platform for government officers to discuss cooperative matters without the participation of the cooperators themselves. This forum was lifted from the Intergovernmental Technical Relations Committee (IGTRC) created under the Intergovernmental Relations Act, 2012.
If such a forum is indeed necessary to monitor the performance of cooperatives in the 47 counties, then fair and square. But just like the defunct District Cooperative Development Committees (DCDCs) formed in the 90s, it can aptly be created through a Commissioner’s Circular, in exercise of the subsidiary powers bestowed on him under Section 93A of the Cooperative Societies Act. I foresee the danger of overlegislating. Some of these peripheral matters can be relegated to the Regulations, since it is easier to amend Regulations and Circulars than Acts of Parliament, which must be returned to Parliament for amendments. This is purely administrative and contains nothing warranting legislation.
When you read the International Cooperative Alliance (ICA) guidelines on legislating for cooperatives globally, the recommendation to member countries is to consider establishing a National Council for Cooperatives (NCC). There, cooperatives and policymakers would meet once, or twice, annually to review the performance of the sector and chart the way forward as partners. Such a forum could be co-hosted or co-chaired by the apex body and the CCD.
While working in Thika District in the 90s, I served as pioneer secretary to the DCDC, which had been created countrywide through a Commissioner’s Circular for the same purpose. It served the sector very well as an administrative intervention intended to promote and foster harmony among cooperatives in the district. In a deliberate and pragmatic way, cooperatives must have fidelity to the cooperative principles that recognise them as member-owned and member-controlled enterprises. This fidelity should not be demonstrated through lip service.
READ:
Kenyans face earlier KRA tax filing deadline for individuals
In line with the ICA recommendation, and as further buttressed by the Model Law developed by the Pan African Parliament (PAP) in June 2024, it is time to progressively align our laws to the evolving ways of managing cooperatives in contemporary times. Indeed, it is high time we thought about the necessity of adopting the “eyes on, hands off” approach as we embrace self-regulation anchored in the National Policy, advocated by the ICA and domesticated into the Model Law intended to set the African standard. Which other country in Africa should be championing such reforms if not Kenya? Incidentally, Kenya is home to the incumbent chair of ICA Africa Region as well as the continental headquarters of ICA Africa Region.
My prayer is that, in order to radically transform our cooperatives in line with the National Cooperative Policy, 2019, we resist the temptation of clawing back the gains already made under the current law. Let us give the Model Law for cooperatives in Africa a chance, having been developed by Moshi Cooperative University in conjunction with ICA Africa and embodying very well researched guidance. The starting point is to recognise the need to create a formal forum, whether in the Act or through a Commissioner’s Circular, to operationalise the National Council for Cooperatives as a platform for regularly bringing together movement and government policymakers and regulators.
I would be grateful to get feedback from the honourable members of this platform, as I reserve my further comments on the Bill until it is gazetted. My instinct tells me that, going by history, the commencement date for this Act shall be December 31, 2026.
By Fred Sitati
Consultant with the Cooperative Movement
Get more stories from our website: Sacco Review.
For comments and clarifications, write to: Saccoreview@
Kindly follow us via our social media pages on Facebook: Sacco Review Newspaper for timely updates
Stay ahead of the pack! Grab the latest Sacco Review newspaper!



